m*******l
发帖数: 469 | 1 最近很多人被0002RFE或NOID，讲讲我的经验回馈本版, 祝大家一切顺利。
Publications, 9 papers, 11 conf proceedings/abstracts, 2 books.
Review: 50
Citations: increased from 40+ (initial submission) to 80+ after I did a
thorough search of various database and the papers/conf proceedings/thesis
of my peers.
Claim: Authorship, Judge, and Contribution
RFE: Contribution and Totality
My experience is to find more hard facts to support your contribution and
international recognition.
Three areas that I focused on:
1. citations. I found 40 more citations in the 3 months after RFE (
increased from 40+ to 80+). Search thesis and other citations from google or
other search databases. Compare your citation to average and top 1% or 0.1%
citation and that of top10 faculty's citation. Use it in both authorship
and contribution.
2. Find facts to support your contribution, such as good comments on your
articles in your citations and anynomous reviews, inquiry letter about
your research, media reports, invoice/lease of your innovations, award to
your innovation, use of your innovations in others' research or real world (
from google search, white papers, or support letters), invitation to be
conference speaker or TPC member (list peers), etc.
3. Ask for editor's support letters. Compare your review frequency to
average frequency. Add your editorial board membership and expert/
adjucative reviewer roles, and add invitations to be guest editor in the RFE
.
Take your time to write your RFE to accumulate your citations and make it
easy to read through. Suggest using bullet point format to list the key
points and stress why you are recognized as outstanding in each of the
criteria. It seems that 0002 likes to read exhibits rather than petition
letter, so I added a brief explanation as cover page of each of my exhibits.
Another tip is to divide your
exhibits for one criterion into one category, such as A1-10 (Authorship), B1
-20(Contribution），C1-10(Review).
Good Luck to everyone! | m******r
发帖数: 854 | | b****j
发帖数: 2414 | | k********g
发帖数: 1686 | 4 Thanks! 还是祈祷到时候提交时别落入杀手。 | y****g
发帖数: 640 | 5 请假下adjudicative reviewer是怎么吹的，我做过三次，其中一次在rfe之后，不知道
是否可以用。拿不到编辑直接表扬的信
【在 m*******l 的大作中提到】
: 最近很多人被0002RFE或NOID，讲讲我的经验回馈本版, 祝大家一切顺利。
: Publications, 9 papers, 11 conf proceedings/abstracts, 2 books.
: Review: 50
: Citations: increased from 40+ (initial submission) to 80+ after I did a
: thorough search of various database and the papers/conf proceedings/thesis
: of my peers.
: Claim: Authorship, Judge, and Contribution
: RFE: Contribution and Totality
: My experience is to find more hard facts to support your contribution and
: international recognition.
| m*******l
发帖数: 469 | 6 这个只好找编辑要吧。不用过分表扬，只要承认就行解释清楚什么role.
【在 y****g 的大作中提到】
: 请假下adjudicative reviewer是怎么吹的，我做过三次，其中一次在rfe之后，不知道
: 是否可以用。拿不到编辑直接表扬的信
| y****g
发帖数: 640 | 7 不肯用模版，给的信没有写明做过几次adjudicative reviewer,但是邀请信上到有写明
是adjudicative，这样能用么
【在 m*******l 的大作中提到】
: 这个只好找编辑要吧。不用过分表扬，只要承认就行解释清楚什么role.
| m*******l
发帖数: 469 | 8 个人认为可以。如果能顺便介绍杂志如何牛，如何选的adjudicative就景上添花了
【在 y****g 的大作中提到】
: 不肯用模版，给的信没有写明做过几次adjudicative reviewer,但是邀请信上到有写明
: 是adjudicative，这样能用么
| c*********7
发帖数: 19373 | | G*******d
发帖数: 359 | 10 Thank you so much!!
请问楼主是哪个field? | | | c*********7
发帖数: 19373 | 11 0002可能是理工出身，不愿意读文字。所以材料扫几眼就写REF。他关心的是citation
数量是否>500,review数量是否>50。否则都认为totality不够。最好的方法是上图，上
表。这样比较直观，省的他读文字漏掉。 | m*******l
发帖数: 469 | 12 1B
【在 c*********7 的大作中提到】
: 1A or 1B?
| S*********n
发帖数: 895 | 13 thanks for sharing
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.5
【在 m*******l 的大作中提到】
: 最近很多人被0002RFE或NOID，讲讲我的经验回馈本版, 祝大家一切顺利。
: Publications, 9 papers, 11 conf proceedings/abstracts, 2 books.
: Review: 50
: Citations: increased from 40+ (initial submission) to 80+ after I did a
: thorough search of various database and the papers/conf proceedings/thesis
: of my peers.
: Claim: Authorship, Judge, and Contribution
: RFE: Contribution and Totality
: My experience is to find more hard facts to support your contribution and
: international recognition.
| c******s
发帖数: 283 | 14 Very nice. Thanks for sharing!
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 m*******l 的大作中提到】
: 最近很多人被0002RFE或NOID，讲讲我的经验回馈本版, 祝大家一切顺利。
: Publications, 9 papers, 11 conf proceedings/abstracts, 2 books.
: Review: 50
: Citations: increased from 40+ (initial submission) to 80+ after I did a
: thorough search of various database and the papers/conf proceedings/thesis
: of my peers.
: Claim: Authorship, Judge, and Contribution
: RFE: Contribution and Totality
: My experience is to find more hard facts to support your contribution and
: international recognition.
| x*****a
发帖数: 3056 | |
|
