r********a
发帖数: 8 | 1 小弟msme， 学校里做的是dynamics, control and mechatronics 主要的都是
programming方面. 感觉3流学校的phd工作前景太渺茫， 又拼不过EE和CS里做control 人
， 过了qualify 以后就学了点CAD/CAE的东西，仗着力学基础扎实，就拿了硕士走了
mechanical design 这条路。 开始到现在跳了三次槽， package 从solid eade, pro/E,
solidworks, 到UG, ANSYS 也都玩过了。GDT，spc,啥的也搞了个八九不离。做的东西从
machine到electronics packaging. 但是总感觉东西做不深， 越来越象体力活， 设计这
个东西到后来就是个trade off，什么东西work不work全靠经验，活干到这份上，感觉很
boring 了。
现在很茫然，mba 里去读个technology managerment. 要么再去出钱读个牛校phd，EE,
BME,CS,或者还是ME. 选择很多， 但是不知道对mechanical design 背景 的跳哪个比较
好 | s****e
发帖数: 334 | 2 兄弟工作几年了？跳槽太频繁了？
我也是感觉DESIGN很多时候都是靠的经验，公司有些老工程师连DEGREE都没得也混的很好
。
跟公司新进来的一个GE跳槽过来的工程师聊聊。。。感觉就是不一样。。。。
现在就看能不能在公司的中国区业务帮点什么，作为突破口。。 | m****l
发帖数: 22 | 3 兄弟,你牛啊~~
design 的, 没有你不懂得阿.:)
不过,我也觉得design engineer 是靠经验, 还蛮耗时间和体力的.
你可以尝试转向design and analysis engineer,
像你这么熟悉design, 又懂ansys, 比起很多anlysis engineer 有优势多了.
大家以后多交流 :)
人
E,
从
这
很
Teamster (cane) 于 (Fri Aug 4 21:08:34 2006) 提到:
ft,不是说你啊
了
屁
【在 r********a 的大作中提到】
: 小弟msme， 学校里做的是dynamics, control and mechatronics 主要的都是
: programming方面. 感觉3流学校的phd工作前景太渺茫， 又拼不过EE和CS里做control 人
: ， 过了qualify 以后就学了点CAD/CAE的东西，仗着力学基础扎实，就拿了硕士走了
: mechanical design 这条路。 开始到现在跳了三次槽， package 从solid eade, pro/E,
: solidworks, 到UG, ANSYS 也都玩过了。GDT，spc,啥的也搞了个八九不离。做的东西从
: machine到electronics packaging. 但是总感觉东西做不深， 越来越象体力活， 设计这
: 个东西到后来就是个trade off，什么东西work不work全靠经验，活干到这份上，感觉很
: boring 了。
: 现在很茫然，mba 里去读个technology managerment. 要么再去出钱读个牛校phd，EE,
: BME,CS,或者还是ME. 选择很多， 但是不知道对mechanical design 背景 的跳哪个比较
| i**c
发帖数: 960 | 4 我也有困惑,在学校里真正学desgin的么有多少,
是不是好多都要分析或者力学,热学背景的.
哪些画图软件是不是都要自学的.
me的design是零件,仪器还是mems的?
仪器设备desgin还是有点
人
E,
从
这
很
UoGQ錞}
陽o8 艌墐q吨`,^蝶鮀X阇襞墐
鐙屋|q泥玱r橄陂t:漀в閠:濐龉d稿M$名禕闙
咣.YLS嶮T鐹gt;UVa咞a
迊
J芓U]A∥9墆'%瞒J屴(Qquot;1!Fb舝夶闛曍饚D隟$詯pV懜WBQ壢
l豷Q囹1伀v}'`皭蝝糕袩Ｗ閠:7睭赙蹮秈徾?蠓邵[吡鈦餇甏幭⒂閠螧踡Y熣交?鸤1(
凈t儾
b嘟c
^冭隣V唀藶8~d~癁諪/潰oв閠OEF絁i竝d鎫蔘驢鞆纎/3c蠬簦句O#耄育綿亮矕蘵鞡菟櫻悐3V緃F
【在 r********a 的大作中提到】
: 小弟msme， 学校里做的是dynamics, control and mechatronics 主要的都是
: programming方面. 感觉3流学校的phd工作前景太渺茫， 又拼不过EE和CS里做control 人
: ， 过了qualify 以后就学了点CAD/CAE的东西，仗着力学基础扎实，就拿了硕士走了
: mechanical design 这条路。 开始到现在跳了三次槽， package 从solid eade, pro/E,
: solidworks, 到UG, ANSYS 也都玩过了。GDT，spc,啥的也搞了个八九不离。做的东西从
: machine到electronics packaging. 但是总感觉东西做不深， 越来越象体力活， 设计这
: 个东西到后来就是个trade off，什么东西work不work全靠经验，活干到这份上，感觉很
: boring 了。
: 现在很茫然，mba 里去读个technology managerment. 要么再去出钱读个牛校phd，EE,
: BME,CS,或者还是ME. 选择很多， 但是不知道对mechanical design 背景 的跳哪个比较
| S*******l
发帖数: 2747 | 5 "全靠经验" basically yes
人
E,
从
这
很
较
【在 r********a 的大作中提到】
: 小弟msme， 学校里做的是dynamics, control and mechatronics 主要的都是
: programming方面. 感觉3流学校的phd工作前景太渺茫， 又拼不过EE和CS里做control 人
: ， 过了qualify 以后就学了点CAD/CAE的东西，仗着力学基础扎实，就拿了硕士走了
: mechanical design 这条路。 开始到现在跳了三次槽， package 从solid eade, pro/E,
: solidworks, 到UG, ANSYS 也都玩过了。GDT，spc,啥的也搞了个八九不离。做的东西从
: machine到electronics packaging. 但是总感觉东西做不深， 越来越象体力活， 设计这
: 个东西到后来就是个trade off，什么东西work不work全靠经验，活干到这份上，感觉很
: boring 了。
: 现在很茫然，mba 里去读个technology managerment. 要么再去出钱读个牛校phd，EE,
: BME,CS,或者还是ME. 选择很多， 但是不知道对mechanical design 背景 的跳哪个比较
| f*****r
发帖数: 138 | 6 本人本科毕业后做了8年的MACHINE DESIGN. 设计就是经验,特别是对民用产品. 感觉你可
以向FEA方向靠. | r********a
发帖数: 8 | 7 2楼
我工作两年多, 为了先是为了半H1-b 跳,再是为了办绿卡跳, 最喜欢第一个工作了,
经费用不完, 不管订什么东西都是overnight, 车间里有5轴机床, 也又braker, 基本
炊寄茏约鹤 technitians是退伍军人, 做事很认真还老是讲故事, 可惜是军工企业.
后来帮台湾人做电子产品的包装.
到现在又回到夕阳行业, 就是为了个绿卡啊. 公司里5个机械工程师 只有2个有学位.
3楼
analysis 都是大公司找, 好多都不办绿卡的. 兄弟如果知道什么公司办, 请多指
现在design 重要的feature都要analysis一把的. 还有concept design 的时候也是.
不过大多象pro mechanica 就够了.
4楼
什么都是靠自己学的. 说实在的, 很羡慕那些做的东西和学的东西一样的人, 那才叫
一帆风顺啊, 感觉大多数人没有这个命啊.
5楼
有经验的机械工程师工资还是可以的, 但是凤毛麟角啊
6楼
这位是大拿啊
我现在设计的是工业产品, FEA是家常便饭啊, 但是都不是很深, 一般只关心first
order然后再给一个暴大的safety fa | r*******c
发帖数: 1 | 8 Admire.
You learned a lot of design tools. As far as I know, Ansys and CosmosWorks are
quite popular now. There should be quite a bit good jobs requiring
experiences of FEA with those tools. Such as Seagate (hard-disc manufacturer?)
.
I am pretty new in this area. May I ask for a copy some electronic handbooks
from you? Thanks.
Fellow in the same boat.
人
E,
【在 r********a 的大作中提到】
: 小弟msme， 学校里做的是dynamics, control and mechatronics 主要的都是
: programming方面. 感觉3流学校的phd工作前景太渺茫， 又拼不过EE和CS里做control 人
: ， 过了qualify 以后就学了点CAD/CAE的东西，仗着力学基础扎实，就拿了硕士走了
: mechanical design 这条路。 开始到现在跳了三次槽， package 从solid eade, pro/E,
: solidworks, 到UG, ANSYS 也都玩过了。GDT，spc,啥的也搞了个八九不离。做的东西从
: machine到electronics packaging. 但是总感觉东西做不深， 越来越象体力活， 设计这
: 个东西到后来就是个trade off，什么东西work不work全靠经验，活干到这份上，感觉很
: boring 了。
: 现在很茫然，mba 里去读个technology managerment. 要么再去出钱读个牛校phd，EE,
: BME,CS,或者还是ME. 选择很多， 但是不知道对mechanical design 背景 的跳哪个比较
| f******a
发帖数: 25 | 9 admire
br />
.
【在 r********a 的大作中提到】
: 2楼
: 我工作两年多, 为了先是为了半H1-b 跳,再是为了办绿卡跳, 最喜欢第一个工作了,
: 经费用不完, 不管订什么东西都是overnight, 车间里有5轴机床, 也又braker, 基本
: 炊寄茏约鹤 technitians是退伍军人, 做事很认真还老是讲故事, 可惜是军工企业.
: 后来帮台湾人做电子产品的包装.
: 到现在又回到夕阳行业, 就是为了个绿卡啊. 公司里5个机械工程师 只有2个有学位.
: 3楼
: analysis 都是大公司找, 好多都不办绿卡的. 兄弟如果知道什么公司办, 请多指
: 现在design 重要的feature都要analysis一把的. 还有concept design 的时候也是.
: 不过大多象pro mechanica 就够了.
| n******i
发帖数: 598 | 10 My company is at dallas, TX. I find it in monster. You can find many design
jobs over there. Usually, they require at least 1-2 yrs working experience.
Anyway, you can find small company to start-up and they are willing to find
entry-level. I learn autocad and pro/e by myself. Download some tutorials in
website. Remember, practice is more important. Of course, if you study the
product design, CAD/CAM in college, you have more chance to land the jobs. | | | s*******s
发帖数: 133 | 11
would you mind sharing your experience on how to land on a design job?
were you very familiar with autocad or pro/e when you were on market? thanks
【在 n******i 的大作中提到】
: My company is at dallas, TX. I find it in monster. You can find many design
: jobs over there. Usually, they require at least 1-2 yrs working experience.
: Anyway, you can find small company to start-up and they are willing to find
: entry-level. I learn autocad and pro/e by myself. Download some tutorials in
: website. Remember, practice is more important. Of course, if you study the
: product design, CAD/CAM in college, you have more chance to land the jobs.
| n******i
发帖数: 598 | 12 I am also working as design engineer for 1.5yrs. My duty is to design and
FEA. FE is only the linear material and non-linear contact analysis. My
background is fracture, fatigue mechanics, and nothing related to design
before. I think design jobs is pretty good in US, although, outsouring to
China or India is very popuplar. I strongly agree with the fact that
experience is important compared with education. I need to understand and
know the parts or components can be machined or not when you des | p*t
发帖数: 1210 | 13 what is the FEA software you are using? Is pro/mechanica enough for assembly
analysis or contact analysis?
to
【在 n******i 的大作中提到】
: I am also working as design engineer for 1.5yrs. My duty is to design and
: FEA. FE is only the linear material and non-linear contact analysis. My
: background is fracture, fatigue mechanics, and nothing related to design
: before. I think design jobs is pretty good in US, although, outsouring to
: China or India is very popuplar. I strongly agree with the fact that
: experience is important compared with education. I need to understand and
: know the parts or components can be machined or not when you des
| n******i
发帖数: 598 | 14 I use ansys and abaqus. Most of the case, for linear problem or non-linear
contact problem, prp/mechanica is enough. | a***8
发帖数: 2433 | 15 I'm also a ME with MS. I got my first job coz I know Pro/E,I got my second
job coz I know Pro/E and FEA. Just like you, doing this basic design day in
and day out get me really bored. I think too much tech skills is not very
good either. Now I'm doing project management, find ideas, solve problems,
most importantly, get all kinds of help from whoever can help, so I don't
have to do it myself. this way, I get more time think of ideas then doing
the 体力活, working is now a lot more enjoyable.
Engine | g****r
发帖数: 14 | 16 Great!
How many years did you spend to do the boring work?
Does CAD like Pro/E is very important to find a job in ME in the beginning?
I am familiar with FEA but not CAD tools, is it necessary to make myself
familiar with those CAD tools in jobhunting?
Thanks!
in
When
Throw
【在 a***8 的大作中提到】
: I'm also a ME with MS. I got my first job coz I know Pro/E,I got my second
: job coz I know Pro/E and FEA. Just like you, doing this basic design day in
: and day out get me really bored. I think too much tech skills is not very
: good either. Now I'm doing project management, find ideas, solve problems,
: most importantly, get all kinds of help from whoever can help, so I don't
: have to do it myself. this way, I get more time think of ideas then doing
: the 体力活, working is now a lot more enjoyable.
: Engine
| a***8
发帖数: 2433 | 17 5 1/2 yrs. tooo long coz GC. After that my ex-boss still want me be his
cattle, I found another job and start moving up.
For your first job out of college, CAD is basic, you may need several under
your belt. They won't trust you on making decisions coz you can't show
successful samples. Just like others said, this is a field "全靠经验".
Also, having broad knowledge base helps. People like "rachelpapa" will have
a easier time finding new job since he knows everything in enginering, not
only ME. EE, C | t**********6
发帖数: 565 | 18 Thanks for your sharings! Admire you very much~~
One simple question,
How did you get that project management job?
Did you take some management courses, such as MBA, to get it?
Thanks a lot!
under
have
【在 a***8 的大作中提到】
: 5 1/2 yrs. tooo long coz GC. After that my ex-boss still want me be his
: cattle, I found another job and start moving up.
: For your first job out of college, CAD is basic, you may need several under
: your belt. They won't trust you on making decisions coz you can't show
: successful samples. Just like others said, this is a field "全靠经验".
: Also, having broad knowledge base helps. People like "rachelpapa" will have
: a easier time finding new job since he knows everything in enginering, not
: only ME. EE, C
| a***8
发帖数: 2433 | 19 Everyone here on this board is very strong technically, as matter of fact, I
think a lot of us are the "tech center" of the group he's in. We all have
advanced degree, MS at least, so nothing need to proove acadamicly. I think
an other degree like MBA won't help much, at least in ME area.
Three things I think are important. first, you gotta have a good boss, the
boss that builds people, helps people on their goal. If you don't have one,
find yourself one. Luck plays a big roll in this case.
Seco |
|
